Can Job Shadowing Give You An Edge in the Application Process?

Can Job Shadowing Give You An Edge in the Application Process?

CareerConnectors.org

Discover how job shadowing can significantly enhance the job application process through exclusive insights from industry experts. This article delves into the strategic benefits of gaining real-world exposure and how it can make applicants stand out. Learn to leverage shadowing experiences to tailor applications for a competitive edge in today’s job market.

  • Job Shadowing Provides Advantage in Job Search
  • Connect Genuinely During Job Shadowing
  • Tailor Applications with Job Shadowing Experience
  • Gain Invaluable Insights Through Job Shadowing
  • Understand Job Functions Through Shadowing
  • Stand Out with Job Shadowing Experience
  • Shadowing Offers Edge in Executive Recruitment
  • Show Initiative Through Job Shadowing
  • Job Shadowing Brings Different Perspective

Job Shadowing Provides Advantage in Job Search

Job shadowing can provide an advantage in a job search whether you are an experienced person or a recent graduate. When I still did recruiting and was considering a change, I shadowed two people at a firm I was considering joining to get a flavor of the environment and observe what it was like to work there. I asked smart questions and, in doing so, gained two advocates for my joining. I also learned of some of the issues in the firm so I was not surprised and could respond properly if any surfaced. 

As a recent grad, Arnold shadowed a senior developer for a day and noticed what others were doing and not doing. In doing so, he found the workplace repugnant and chose not to join even when offered a job. In both of our cases, we understood surprises are rarely good and in my case allowed me to prepare for situations and overcome them and in Arnold’s choice not to deal with such headaches.

Jeff Altman, Global Job Search Coach, The Big Game Hunter, Inc.

Connect Genuinely During Job Shadowing

Yes! I believe that a job shadowing experience can give you an advantage during an application process if done effectively at the place you want to work. I recommend that job seekers use job shadowing as a way to genuinely connect with others in that workplace. This is accomplished by asking questions and assisting others when possible during your job shadowing experience. If you prove yourself to be a valuable asset during this process, this can give you a competitive advantage over others. It has been proven that the career opportunities you want are granted via credible referrals, and this exercise is a great way to get them.

Michelle Enjoli, Career Development Speaker and Coach, Michelle Enjoli International

Tailor Applications with Job Shadowing Experience

Job shadowing can definitely provide a competitive edge in the application process because the candidate will be able to specifically tailor their application materials to reflect real-life experience. Furthermore, this experience provides further insight into what the role is day-to-day, as well as the organizational culture, team environment, and other office dynamics in which the candidate can draw parallels to align with what they are looking for in a company/team. After the application process, this experience also translates well to the interview setting and smooth onboarding by already being exposed to having a better understanding of the role expectations and what success looks like.

Megan Dias, Career Services Coach, Parsity

Gain Invaluable Insights Through Job Shadowing

Job shadowing can provide invaluable insights that not only give you a competitive edge during the application process but also deepen your understanding of the competencies required for a role.

When you shadow someone in a position you aspire to, you’re not just observing their daily tasks—you’re gaining a firsthand look at the core skills and behaviors that make them successful. This experience allows you to bridge the gap between theoretical knowledge and practical application.

For instance, if you’re shadowing a leader in a project management role, you’ll see how they prioritize tasks, communicate with stakeholders, and make quick, strategic decisions under pressure. These are all competencies—like decision-making, time management, and interpersonal communication—that hiring managers value deeply.

I recall a client who shadowed a marketing director before applying for a similar role. Through that experience, they identified key areas for their own growth, like presenting data-driven insights with confidence. They later took a competency assessment to track their progress, which allowed them to articulate their competency development during the interview. That proactive approach ultimately helped them secure the position.

Competencies are the foundation of career success, and job shadowing is an excellent way to identify, develop, and showcase those strengths to stand out in the hiring process.

Linda Scorzo, CEO, Hiring Indicators

Understand Job Functions Through Shadowing

Job shadowing can be a powerful advantage during the application process, particularly for roles that require a keen understanding of specific job functions and industry nuances. It not only shows a candidate’s proactive interest in the field but also offers them a hands-on perspective on the necessary skills and challenges of the role.

Take, for example, someone new to the role of a software implementation consultant. If this person has had the opportunity to shadow an experienced consultant, they would gain invaluable insights into the day-to-day realities of the job. This could include observing how the consultant interacts with clients, manages the software build/deployment, troubleshoots issues in real-time, and adapts solutions to meet specific client needs. During an interview, the candidate could discuss specific situations they observed, such as how the consultant navigated a complex implementation or resolved a client’s concern, demonstrating a direct understanding of the role’s demands and complexities.

Additionally, job shadowing helps build professional networks within the industry. This can lead to endorsements from seasoned professionals, further strengthening a candidate’s credibility and appeal to potential employers. Essentially, the practical knowledge and connections gained from shadowing can distinctly elevate a candidate’s profile, showing their readiness and dedication to excel in their desired career path.

Tia Smith, VP, Global Talent, Cognizant

Stand Out with Job Shadowing Experience

Yes, job shadowing experience can provide a significant advantage during the application process by demonstrating hands-on exposure and practical understanding of a role. For example, we’ve seen candidates with job shadowing experience stand out when applying for roles like virtual assistants or project coordinators. 

One standout candidate had shadowed a remote team lead for two weeks, learning about task delegation, communication via Slack, and using tools like Trello for project tracking. During the interview, they were able to share specific insights, like how they observed task prioritization or streamlined workflows. 

This real-world experience showed initiative, a proactive learning mindset, and familiarity with the tools and processes used in the role, making them an ideal hire. Job shadowing provides candidates with valuable context that can differentiate them from those with only theoretical knowledge.

Nick Esquivel, CEO, Globaltize

Shadowing Offers Edge in Executive Recruitment

We strongly believe that job shadowing can be a game-changer in the application process. Our experience working with senior executives has repeatedly shown that candidates who’ve invested time in job shadowing often have a distinct edge over their competitors. Let us share a recent success story from our practice. 

We worked with a senior operations executive who had spent two weeks shadowing a retiring COO as part of a succession planning initiative. This experience proved invaluable during the selection process. Not only did they gain practical insights into the company’s operational challenges, but they also developed a deep understanding of the organizational culture and key stakeholder relationships. 

What really made a difference is that they were able to observe real-time decision-making, understand the nuances of leadership dynamics, and identify potential areas for improvement through job shadowing. When presenting their vision during the final interview, they could speak with authority about specific challenges and opportunities, having witnessed them firsthand. 

We find that job shadowing offers three crucial advantages in executive recruitment. First, it provides authentic exposure to leadership dynamics that can’t be learned from job descriptions alone. Second, it allows candidates to demonstrate their commitment to understanding the role deeply. Finally, it helps build meaningful relationships within the organization—something we’ve seen make a significant difference in final hiring decisions. 

In our experience, executives who embrace job shadowing opportunities often transition more smoothly into their new roles and achieve success more quickly. Outside of just observing, it’s about gaining practical insights that can set you apart in a competitive leadership marketplace.

Julia Yurchak, Talent Sourcing, Acquisition & Management Specialist| Senior Recruitment Consultant, Keller Executive Search

Show Initiative Through Job Shadowing

Yes, job shadowing can provide a clear advantage during the application process. Just as what is commonly done in the restaurant industry. It creates an opportunity for the prospective employee to demonstrate initiative, genuine interest, and a proactive approach to career exploration-qualities that employers value. Shadowing also offers firsthand insight into a role, allowing candidates to speak knowledgeably about the job and how their skills align. 

For example, a college graduate interested in marketing might shadow a marketing manager for a week, gaining exposure to campaign planning and market research. In an interview, they could say, “During my shadowing experience, I observed how marketing teams analyze consumer behavior to design targeted campaigns. This inspired me, and I’m eager to contribute to similar initiatives in this role.” 

This real-world understanding not only sets candidates apart but also helps build professional connections, which can lead to referrals or recommendations. By showcasing practical experience and a deeper understanding of the role, job shadowing becomes a powerful tool in standing out to employers.

Andrea Briscoe, CEO, Sage Consulting

Job Shadowing Brings Different Perspective

You know how everyone talks about the importance of “real-world experience?” Well, I’ve seen firsthand how job shadowing can be a game-changer in the hiring process. It’s fascinating to see how candidates who’ve spent time observing professionals at work bring such a different perspective to the table.

We’ve put our own spin on this idea. With permission, we record hiring interviews to help candidates learn and improve. It’s been incredible to see how this helps people understand what employers are really looking for and ace their next interviews.

Let me share a quick story that really drives this home. We once hired a developer whose formal education was pretty basic, but they had shadowed a senior engineer at a major tech company. During the interview, they blew us away by describing specific solutions they’d learned from their shadowing experience. They got the job and turned out to be a fantastic addition to the team.

George Fironov, Co-Founder & CEO, Talmatic

 

About the author

Leave a Comment, Thought, Opinion. Speak like you're speaking with someone you love.

Is Work Not Working?

Instead of talking to Your Wife, Husband, or Partner, Schedule a Time With a Career Expert.